Here’s a bold statement: BYU’s football program is on the brink of something historic. But here’s where it gets controversial—is this the best recruiting class in school history, or just a promising step forward? Let’s dive in.
BYU’s roster has received a significant boost with the addition of returned missionaries and strategic transfers, marking what many are calling a transformative period for the program. During a recent Zoom meeting, offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick and head coach Kalani Sitake shed light on the program’s ambitious moves. Roderick aptly summarized the complexity of modern recruiting: ‘It’s not just about high school signings anymore. We’re also integrating returned missionaries and transfer portal players, making it harder to summarize but incredibly rewarding.’
And this is the part most people miss: BYU’s 2026 recruiting class is ranked No. 21 nationally and No. 2 in the Big 12 by 247Sports, making it the program’s most impressive high school haul to date. While no new prep signings were announced on Wednesday, the 21 players signed in December remain a cornerstone of this class. Additionally, the nine transfer portal additions previously announced have solidified BYU’s depth and talent.
Sitake praised the recruiting department’s efforts, stating, ‘They connected the right people to our recruits, whether from high school or the transfer portal, and showcased what BYU stands for. The result? A stellar recruiting class and a strong transfer group.’
New defensive coordinator Kelly Poppinga, stepping in after Jay Hill’s departure to Michigan, highlighted the impact of Cal transfer linebacker Cade Uluave, calling him ‘a big pickup.’ Poppinga also noted that the additions have made BYU’s defense the deepest it’s been since he joined the staff three years ago. ‘On paper, this is the best recruiting class in BYU history,’ he boldly declared. But is it too early to crown this class as the greatest? That’s a debate worth having.
Eight returned missionaries have joined the program as midyear enrollees, including notable players like linebacker Owen Borg, tight end Matthew Fredrick, and quarterback Enoch Watson. Sitake expressed optimism about their immediate impact, though he cautioned, ‘We’ll know more once spring practices begin. These guys are hungry, but we need to bring them along slowly after their time away from the game.’
BYU’s coaching staff has also seen significant changes. Justin Ena was promoted to special teams coordinator, Chad Kauha’aha’a to outside linebackers coach, and Lewis Walker was hired as cornerbacks coach. Former New England Patriots assistant Tyler Hughes joins as assistant QBs coach, with Roderick noting, ‘Tyler’s a really good coach, and the timing just felt right.’
But here’s a thought-provoking question: With all these additions, is BYU’s roster complete for 2026? Sitake and Roderick suggest they’re likely finished, barring unexpected opportunities. However, Roderick added, ‘We’re never fully satisfied. There’s always a chance we’ll add another good player if the opportunity arises.’
One area fans are watching closely is the running back position. With LJ Martin’s injury history and Sione Moa’s health concerns, could BYU add another experienced back? Roderick highlighted incoming freshman DeVaughn Eka as a potential immediate contributor, saying, ‘I wouldn’t be surprised if he plays this year. He’s a very talented kid.’
As BYU prepares for spring practices starting February 27, the excitement is palpable. But the real question remains: Will this class live up to the hype, or is it too early to tell? Share your thoughts in the comments—let’s spark a debate!
